1031 Exchanges and Short Sales
-Investment Property Exchange Services, Inc.
We are often asked whether the seller of investment property in a short sale can benefit from a 1031 exchange. The answer is yes. According to IPX 1031 Regional Manager, Jim Miller, in a short sale the lender is agreeing to release the property that is being sold from the lien of its Mortgage. Since the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act of 2007 only applies to a principal residence, any debt forgiveness with regard to an investment property will be taxable.
For example, let’s assume Ian Investor purchased 123 Main Street in 2005 for $240,000 with 100% financing. Over the past few years, the value of 123 Main Street has decreased and it is now only worth $200,000. Although Ian remains current on his loan payments he does not want to continue to own 123 Main Street because of its decreased value. Accordingly, he decides to sell 123 Main Street. His real estate agent finds a buyer and states the bank is willing to agree to accept $200,000 in a “short sale”.
Although this is good news, Ian’s accountant advises him that the debt forgiveness of nearly $40,000 (approximately $240,000 minus $200,000) will result in a tax liability of between eight and twelve thousand dollars. Ian does not want to pay taxes to sell a property that has already lost $40,000 in value and decides that a short sale is not a good option for him.
Ian’s accountant suggests that he have his real estate agent contact his current bank to see if they are willing to exchange 123 Main Street with one of its “Bank Owned” properties. The benefit to the lender is that Ian is still solvent but “underwater” in 123 Main Street.; and by exchanging one of the properties it already owns (as a consequence of a prior foreclosure) Ian will remain financially stable and be more likely to continue paying his mortgage obligation. The benefit to Ian is that he will not be forced to recognize and pay taxes on “phantom income” and he will be able to acquire, as his replacement property, a better property which is equal in value to his original investment.
Accordingly, Ian’s lender agrees to exchange 456 Park Place, worth $240,000, for 123 Main Street and transfer Ian’s loan to the new property. As a result of the exchange, Ian has a better property without recognizing (paying taxes on) any gain. The lender still has one property to sell but has reduced the chance that Ian will walk away from his original $240,000 obligation.
Successfully achieving this type of transaction takes effort but it can be beneficial to investors, lenders and real estate agents. An investor could acquire the new property in an area which has stabilized and has a better chance of showing appreciation. Before selling any property in a short sale, it is very important to consult with your tax advisor. You need to receive competent advice as to what is best for your specific situation. A “do it yourself” approach may result in an unexpected tax bill which could have been reduced or avoided with proper planning.
Filed under: commercial real estate | Tagged: "bank failures", "government spending", "group investing", "lease rates", "lock in", "occupancy levels", "office orlando", "office space orlando", "population growth", "real estate orlando", 1031 Exchanges, bank, ccim, commercial real estate, Commercial real estate lake mary, credit, debt, FDIC, FL, florida weather, foreclosure, lake mary, leasing, Miguel de Arcos, office, oreo, orlando, real estate, reo, short sales, tenant, vacancy | Leave a Comment »




